Sporting Kansas City acquired defender Justin Reynolds from the Chicago Fire in a trade ahead of the 2026 season. Reynolds – a versatile defender that primarily plays right back – arrived at Sporting KC having made 76 professional appearances while representing the Chicago Fire at both the MLS and MLS NEXT Pro level, while he also had a stint on loan with Chicago’s partner club, FC Lugano, in the Swiss Super League.
PROFESSIONAL
2026: Joined Sporting KC at the start of the year after being acquired via trade from the Chicago Fire. Made 18 appearances in all competitions and tallied one goal and two assists. MLS Regular Season: Started 11 of 17 appearances, tallying a goal and two assists throughout the season. Made his debut for the club in the season opener at San Jose (Feb. 21) before tallying his first assist on the road against Real Salt Lake (April 4). Recorded another assist on the opening goal in the 3-1 home win over LAFC (Sept. 12) before scoring his first goal for the club in the 3-3 home draw with Portland (Oct. 10). Open Cup: Started and played the opening 45 minutes of the defeat at Colorado Springs (April 14). MLS NEXT Pro: Made one appearance for SKC II while working back from injury, playing the opening 45 minutes against Colorado Rapids 2 (Aug. 15).
Chicago Fire (2023-2025): Reynolds appeared 14 times for the Chicago Fire first team, including 12 in MLS action, while also playing in 62 matches for Chicago Fire II in MLS NEXT Pro, tallying three goals and six assists. Reynolds joined FC Lugano in Switzerland for a two-month loan in March of 2024, making his lone appearance for the club on the final day of the Swiss Super League season. Upon returning to Chicago, he made his MLS debut as a late substitute against Inter Miami on July 20, 2024 before earning his first start two months later against Toronto FC on Sept. 28, 2024. Reynolds scored his first senior goal for Chicago with the game-winning goal in a wild 5-3 victory over eventual MLS Cup champions Inter Miami at Chase Stadium on Sept. 30, 2025.
INTERNATIONAL
Reynolds represented the United States at the Under-15 and Under-19 levels while with the Chicago Fire and earned his first call up to the U.S. Under-21 National Team in June 2026.
YOUTH
Reynolds, whose older brother Andre Reynolds II was also a Homegrown Player for Chicago, developed in the Fire Academy and was a key part of the team that won the inaugural MLS NEXT U-19 Championship in 2021.